Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. We earn a small commission on purchases at no cost to you. Full disclosure.
If you want the short answer: Nestl wins on fit (True Grip elastic all around vs. Mellanni's corner-only elastic) and Mellanni wins on color variety (44 colors vs. Nestl's 24). On softness, durability, and price, they are virtually identical. For most people, the True Grip fitted sheet makes Nestl the better overall value -- it solves the single most annoying problem with fitted sheets.
Nestl has been selling microfiber sheets on Amazon since the mid-2010s. The brand gained wider recognition when Bed Bath & Beyond licensed their products under the "Nestwell" name in 2021. After BBB's bankruptcy in 2023, Nestl continued selling directly through Amazon. Their standout feature is True Grip -- a full-perimeter elastic fitted sheet that actually stays on your mattress. They offer sheet sets in Twin through Cal King with 24 color options. Read the full Nestwell story.
Mellanni is another established microfiber sheet brand on Amazon, known for their extensive color selection (44+ colors) and competitive pricing. They have been a consistent Amazon Best Seller in the bedding category, with their core product being the 1800 Series microfiber sheet set. Mellanni focuses on value -- delivering soft, wrinkle-free sheets at some of the lowest prices on the platform.
Both brands use brushed microfiber (polyester), and both market their sheets as "1800 Series" or "1800 thread count." As we have discussed in our sheet sets guide, this number is a marketing term for microfiber, not a true cotton-equivalent thread count.
Nestl: Double-brushed microfiber with a slightly more substantial feel. When you first take them out of the package, they feel smooth and have a subtle sheen. After washing, they soften up further while maintaining a structured hand feel.
Mellanni: Also double-brushed microfiber with a very similar initial feel. Mellanni sheets tend to feel slightly thinner and lighter out of the package. After a few washes, the softness is comparable to Nestl. The difference is minimal -- we are talking about a subtle variation that most people would not notice in a blind test.
Winner: Tie. Both brands use similar quality microfiber with double-brushed finishing. The difference in hand feel is marginal and becomes negligible after washing.
This is where the biggest difference between the two brands shows up.
Nestl: All Nestl fitted sheets use True Grip technology -- elastic sewn completely around the perimeter of the sheet, not just at the corners. Standard sets have a 16-inch deep pocket. Extra-deep fitted sheets (sold separately) go up to 21 inches. The True Grip design means the sheet grips the mattress from all sides and does not pop off during the night. Learn more about True Grip.
Mellanni: Mellanni fitted sheets use traditional corner elastic with a 16-inch deep pocket. The elastic quality is decent, but it only creates tension at four points. On thick mattresses, especially those with pillow tops or rounded edges, Mellanni fitted sheets are more likely to slip off compared to Nestl's full-perimeter design.
Winner: Nestl. The True Grip fitted sheet is a genuine product innovation, not just marketing. If you have ever struggled with fitted sheets that pop off, this alone is worth choosing Nestl over Mellanni. It is the single biggest differentiator between these two otherwise-similar brands.
Microfiber sheets in general are more durable than cotton when it comes to pilling resistance. Both Nestl and Mellanni take advantage of this inherent material benefit.
Nestl: After 30+ washes in our testing, Nestl sheets showed no pilling, no significant fading, and no loss of softness. The True Grip elastic maintained its tension. Minor wrinkles appeared in areas that came out of the dryer folded, but smoothed out once placed on the mattress.
Mellanni: Similarly durable -- no pilling after 30+ washes, good color retention, and consistent softness. The corner elastic on the fitted sheet showed slightly more wear than Nestl's full-perimeter elastic, which makes sense since four points are bearing all the tension versus the load being distributed around the entire edge.
Winner: Slight edge to Nestl. Both brands are durable, but Nestl's elastic design distributes stress more evenly, which should translate to longer fitted sheet life.
Neither brand is going to compete with pure cotton percale for breathability. But within the microfiber category, here is how they compare:
Nestl: Nestl markets their sheets as "cooling and breathable." In practice, they are breathable enough for comfortable sleep in rooms kept at 65-72 degrees. Above that, hot sleepers may notice warmth buildup. Nestl's brushed microfiber has a slightly denser weave that retains a bit more warmth -- which is actually a benefit in colder months.
Mellanni: Similar breathability profile. Mellanni's slightly thinner construction may provide marginally better airflow, but the difference is minimal. Neither brand offers a significant cooling advantage over the other.
Winner: Tie. Both are "breathable for microfiber" but neither is truly cooling. Hot sleepers should consider cotton percale sheets regardless of brand.
Nestl: 24 color options across most product lines. Colors include the standards (white, ivory, grey, navy, black) plus some distinctive options (eggplant purple, sage green, coral, burgundy). Fade resistance is excellent -- colors look the same after months of washing.
Mellanni: 44+ color options -- nearly double Nestl's selection. Mellanni offers everything Nestl does plus additional variations like baby blue, mint, spa blue, taupe, and multiple shades of grey. If matching a specific bedroom color scheme is important, Mellanni gives you more options.
Winner: Mellanni. Nearly twice as many colors. If you need a very specific shade, Mellanni is more likely to have it.
Both brands compete aggressively on price. Here is how they stack up (prices as of March 2026 on Amazon):
| Product | Nestl Price | Mellanni Price | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Queen 4-Piece Sheet Set | $21.99 | $21.97 | Essentially the same |
| King 4-Piece Sheet Set | $22.99 | $27.97 | Nestl $5 cheaper |
| Twin 3-Piece Sheet Set | $17.99 | $17.97 | Essentially the same |
| King 6-Piece Sheet Set | $27.99 | $32.97 | Nestl $5 cheaper |
| Pillowcases (2-pack) | $9.99 | $9.97 | Essentially the same |
Prices may vary. Check current Amazon prices using the links below.
Winner: Nestl (slight edge). Prices are very close on smaller sizes, but Nestl tends to be $3-5 cheaper on King and 6-piece sets. Given that Nestl also includes True Grip elastic (a premium feature), the value proposition leans in their direction.
Both brands have massive review counts on Amazon, which gives us a reliable data set:
| Metric | Nestl | Mellanni |
|---|---|---|
| Average Rating (Sheet Sets) | 4.5 / 5 | 4.5 / 5 |
| Total Reviews (Top Listing) | 52,000+ | 300,000+ |
| Most Common Praise | "Fitted sheet stays on," "Soft," "Great value" | "So soft," "Beautiful colors," "Great price" |
| Most Common Complaint | "Thinner than expected" | "Fitted sheet slips off" |
The most telling data point: Mellanni's most common complaint ("fitted sheet slips off") is exactly the problem that Nestl's True Grip design solves. Nestl's most common complaint ("thinner than expected") is a perception issue that applies to all microfiber sheets compared to thick cotton -- it is not a quality defect.
Winner: Tie on ratings. Both earn 4.5 stars. Mellanni has more total reviews (they have been on Amazon longer with higher volume), but the review sentiment is similar for both brands.
| Feature | Nestl (Nestwell) | Mellanni |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Brushed microfiber | Brushed microfiber |
| Marketing Thread Count | 1800 Series | 1800 Series |
| Brushing | Double-brushed | Double-brushed |
| Fitted Sheet Elastic | Full perimeter (True Grip) | Corners only |
| Standard Pocket Depth | 16 inches | 16 inches |
| Extra Deep Pocket Option | 21 inches | Not available |
| Colors Available | 24 | 44+ |
| Sizes Available | Twin to Split King | Twin to Split King |
| 6-Piece Set Option | Yes | Yes |
| Wrinkle-Free | Yes | Yes |
| Fade-Resistant | Yes | Yes |
| Hypoallergenic | Yes | Yes |
| Pill-Resistant | Yes | Yes |
| Comforter Sets | Yes | Yes |
| Pillowcase Closure | Envelope | Envelope |
| Amazon Rating | 4.5 / 5 | 4.5 / 5 |
| King Set Price | $22.99 | $27.97 |
| Retail Store History | Bed Bath & Beyond (as Nestwell) | Amazon only |
For most people, Nestl is the better buy. The True Grip fitted sheet is a genuine product advantage that addresses the single most common complaint about microfiber sheets (and sheets in general). Add in slightly lower prices on King and 6-piece sets, a 21-inch extra-deep pocket option, and identical material quality, and Nestl wins on value.
Mellanni is a solid alternative if color selection is your top priority. But if you have ever been frustrated by a fitted sheet that will not stay put, Nestl's True Grip technology is worth the switch.